What Does an Abstractof Title Look Like?
An abstract of title is the paper trail behind every Buffalo property — a chronological history of every deed, mortgage, lien, judgment, and encumbrance ever recorded against it. Most homeowners sign at closing without ever understanding what’s inside it. This page changes that.
The Abstract Is the Foundation of Every Closing
Before any title company in Buffalo can issue a title insurance commitment, a licensed abstractor must search the Erie County property records and produce an abstract of title. This document is the physical record of everything that has ever been recorded against your property — going back to the Erie County bar standard starting point of 1920, and sometimes further when chain of title issues require it.
In New York State, an abstract of title is not just paperwork — it is a guaranteed document. The abstractor who produces it attaches a certification and is personally liable for errors in the search. The title insurance company then insures against anything the search missed. Together, the abstract and the title insurance policy are what make real estate ownership legally secure in New York.
For Buffalo homeowners, understanding what an abstract contains — and what it means when something shows up in it — is the difference between a smooth closing and a deal that falls apart at the table. See our full guide to title companies in Buffalo ›
What an Abstract of Title Actually Is
An abstract of title is a condensed, written summary of every document in the public record that affects a specific parcel of real property. It is not the same as a deed or a title — it is the history behind both. Think of it as a legal biography of the property, starting from the earliest recorded source of ownership and running forward to the present day.
In Erie County, every deed, mortgage, discharge, assignment, lien, judgment, tax warrant, mechanic’s lien, lis pendens, in-rem proceeding, bankruptcy filing, and Surrogate’s Court proceeding that touches a property gets recorded with the Erie County Clerk at 92 Franklin Street, Buffalo, NY 14202. The abstractor searches those records — document by document — and summarizes each one in chronological order.
The result is a bound document, often 20 to 100+ pages for older Buffalo properties, that the title examiner reviews to determine whether title is insurable. The examiner reads the abstract, identifies any gaps or defects in the chain of title, notes outstanding liens or encumbrances, and issues a title commitment based on what the abstract reveals.
Erie County bar standard: Every title search in Erie County must go back to at least 1920 and must be guaranteed by a title insurance corporation licensed under Article 64 of the New York Insurance Law. Shorter searches are not acceptable for residential closings in Erie County.
What You’ll Find Inside an Erie County Abstract
A typical Erie County abstract is organized chronologically and contains distinct sections corresponding to different types of recorded instruments. Here is what each section contains and why it matters to a seller:
Every deed recorded against the property since the bar standard start date. Shows who owned it, when they acquired it, how they took title (sole owner, joint tenants, tenants in common), and how they conveyed it. Gaps in this chain are the most serious title defects — they require court action to cure.
Every mortgage ever placed on the property, plus every discharge (payoff). If a discharge is missing for an old mortgage, that lender theoretically still has a claim against the property. Old undischarged mortgages on Buffalo pre-war homes are surprisingly common and must be resolved before closing.
Outstanding Erie County property taxes, City of Buffalo water/sewer charges, school tax arrears, and any in-rem (foreclosure) proceedings. This section is critical for inherited and vacant Buffalo properties where taxes may have gone unpaid for years. See: selling with delinquent taxes in Erie County.
Personal judgments entered against the property owner in Erie County courts. In New York, a judgment against a person automatically attaches to all real property they own in that county. Judgments must be paid or released before title can transfer. IRS tax liens appear here as well.
Liens filed by contractors, subcontractors, or material suppliers who were not paid for work performed on the property. In New York, mechanic’s liens must be filed within 8 months of last work performed. Common on properties with recent renovation history.
Buffalo’s Office of Building Inspection (OBI) files liens when the city performs remediation work on code-violating properties. These are property liens — not personal liens — and attach to the parcel regardless of who owns it. Very common on older East Side, South Buffalo, and First Ward properties. See: code violations guide.
Filed with the Erie County Clerk when a lawsuit affecting the property is pending — most commonly a foreclosure action or estate dispute. A lis pendens is a red flag that the property is in litigation. It must be cancelled or the underlying lawsuit resolved before title can transfer.
For inherited properties, the abstract includes a search of Erie County Surrogate’s Court records to confirm the estate was properly opened, Letters Testamentary or Letters of Administration were issued, and the executor had legal authority to convey. Missing or defective estate proceedings are a common title problem on inherited Buffalo properties. See: Erie County Surrogate’s Court guide.
Deed restrictions, utility easements, and use limitations recorded against the property. These affect what a buyer can do with the property but do not typically prevent a sale. Common in platted subdivisions throughout Amherst, Cheektowaga, and Lancaster.
Federal bankruptcy filings by the property owner. A bankruptcy creates an automatic stay that prevents any transfer of property without court approval. Active bankruptcies must be addressed — often through the bankruptcy court — before closing can proceed.
How Buffalo’s Housing Stock Complicates the Abstract
Erie County’s older housing stock creates title complications that are far less common in newer suburban markets. A 1910 East Side two-family or a 1940s First Ward bungalow may have passed through a dozen owners, multiple estates, informal transfers, and long periods of non-payment. Each one of those events leaves a mark in the abstract — and each one has to be accounted for.
The most common issues Nickel City Buyers encounters in Buffalo abstract searches:
Old undischarged mortgages. A mortgage from 1978 that was paid off but never properly discharged still shows in the abstract. The title company has to locate the original lender (often no longer in business), obtain a discharge, and record it with the Erie County Clerk before the current sale can close.
Missing estate deeds. A property owner dies, family members continue living in the home for years, and no one files the proper estate paperwork. Decades later, the property technically still belongs to a deceased person in the Erie County records. Curing this requires going back to Erie County Surrogate’s Court — a process that can take weeks or months.
Accumulated OBI citations. A property that sat vacant for years may have multiple OBI lien entries in the abstract representing city-performed remediation work. Each one must be resolved before title is clean.
In-rem tax foreclosure proceedings. Erie County and the City of Buffalo both run in-rem foreclosure proceedings for non-payment of taxes. If an in-rem proceeding was filed but not completed, it clouds the title chain until resolved. If it was completed, the property’s ownership history must show the in-rem deed to document the transfer properly.
Nickel City Buyers has closed 300+ transactions through Western New York title companies since 2013. We open title immediately upon signing and work with local WNY title professionals who know Erie County’s specific records systems. We have seen — and resolved — every one of the issues described on this page.
The Abstractor’s Certificate — Why It Matters
Every guaranteed abstract of title in New York State closes with an abstractor’s certificate. This is the abstractor’s written guarantee that they searched the specified records and that the summary they produced accurately reflects what those records contain. The abstractor assumes personal liability for errors in the search.
This is why the Erie County bar standard requires abstracts to be guaranteed by a title insurance corporation licensed under Article 64 of the New York Insurance Law. The abstractor’s guarantee plus the title insurance policy create two layers of protection for the buyer — and together they are what make NYS title insurance different from many other states.
When an investor or cash buyer orders the abstract, that certificate runs to them — not to you. If the deal collapses, the abstractor’s guarantee goes with the investor. You start over. This is the core of why letting your cash buyer pay for title work can cost you weeks and thousands of dollars if the deal falls through.
Who Owns the Abstract — Matters More Than Most Sellers Know
If the buyer orders and pays for the abstract of title, that abstract belongs to the buyer. If the deal falls through for any reason, the buyer is under no obligation to share that abstract, transfer it, or allow it to be used at a subsequent closing. The title company performed the work for the buyer’s benefit — not yours.
That means if you go to sell to a different buyer, the new title company must start the search from scratch. The lien resolution work, the estate deed research, the OBI payoff coordination — all of it starts over. For complex Buffalo properties with multiple title issues, this can mean weeks of additional delay and hundreds of dollars in duplicated search fees.
The protection: engage your own real estate attorney and order your own title search before accepting any offer. When you own the abstract, you control the closing process. See our full guide on why you shouldn’t let your cash buyer pay for title ›
Abstract of Title Buffalo NY — FAQ
How long does a title abstract take in Erie County?
A standard Erie County residential title search and abstract typically takes 5–10 business days from the date the order is placed. Properties with complex histories — multiple estate transfers, accumulated OBI liens, old undischarged mortgages, or in-rem proceedings — can take longer. Nickel City Buyers works with local WNY title companies experienced in Erie County records, which typically results in faster turnaround than working with an out-of-area company unfamiliar with local recording practices.
Is an abstract of title the same as a title report?
They are related but not identical. An abstract of title is the raw chronological summary of all recorded instruments — the physical document the abstractor produces. A title report (or title commitment) is the title company’s analysis of that abstract, organized into Schedule A (what is being insured) and Schedule B (exceptions and requirements). The abstract is the research; the title report is the opinion based on that research. See our guide on how to read a title report in New York State ›
Does the seller get a copy of the abstract?
In most New York State residential transactions, the seller’s attorney receives a copy of the title commitment (the report based on the abstract) and reviews it for issues that the seller needs to resolve. Whether the seller receives the full abstract depends on the transaction structure. In a cash sale, if the buyer orders the abstract, the buyer’s title company controls the document. This is one of the reasons sellers benefit from having their own attorney engaged before accepting any offer — to ensure they are represented in the title review process.
What happens if something bad shows up in the abstract?
Most issues that appear in an Erie County abstract can be resolved before or at closing. Tax liens and back taxes are paid from sale proceeds. Judgment liens are paid off or negotiated with creditors. OBI liens are resolved through the City of Buffalo. Old undischarged mortgages require locating the lender and obtaining a payoff or discharge. More serious defects — deed gaps, missing estate proceedings, active lis pendens — take longer and may require court action. The title company identifies every issue and coordinates resolution as part of the closing process. When Nickel City Buyers purchases your home, we handle all of this — you bring nothing to the table and the liens are resolved from your sale proceeds at closing.
Do I need my own attorney to review the abstract?
In New York State, real estate closings require attorney involvement — but whose attorney reviews the abstract depends on who ordered it. If the buyer’s title company orders and produces the abstract, it is the buyer’s title examiner who reviews it on the buyer’s behalf. A seller without their own attorney has no independent review of the title issues affecting their property. This is why New York State real estate attorneys consistently recommend that sellers engage counsel before accepting any offer — so that the seller has independent representation throughout the title review process.
How far back does an Erie County title search go?
The Erie County Bar Association standard requires title searches to go back to at least 1920, and the search must be guaranteed by a title insurance corporation licensed under Article 64 of the New York Insurance Law. For properties with unusual ownership histories, defective deeds, or missing conveyances, abstractors may search further back. Some Buffalo properties — particularly those in older neighborhoods like the East Side, First Ward, and South Buffalo — have chain-of-title issues that require going back to the original 19th-century land grants to establish a clean ownership history.
What is the difference between an abstract and title insurance?
The abstract is the research — a human-produced summary of public records. Title insurance is the policy that indemnifies the buyer (and any lender) against losses caused by defects in title that were missed in the search or that arise from facts outside the public record. Together they form a two-layer protection system: the abstract identifies known risks; title insurance covers unknown risks. In New York State, title insurance premiums are regulated by the NYS Department of Financial Services and are based on the purchase price of the property. See our full guide to title insurance in Buffalo ›
Buffalo • Cheektowaga • Tonawanda • Amherst • Lackawanna • West Seneca • Hamburg • Orchard Park • Lancaster • Depew • Kenmore • Williamsville • Grand Island • Niagara Falls • Lockport • North Tonawanda • Lewiston • East Amherst • View All Areas ›
Nickel City Buyers — Cash Home Buyers Who Understand Erie County Title Since 2013
Nickel City Buyers, LLC has closed 300+ real estate transactions through Western New York title companies since 2013. Located at 3842 Harlem Rd STE 400-339, Cheektowaga, NY 14215. Phone: (716) 557-7005. We coordinate abstract searches, title resolution, and cash closings across Buffalo, Cheektowaga, Tonawanda, Amherst, Lackawanna, West Seneca, Hamburg, Orchard Park, Lancaster, Depew, Kenmore, Williamsville, Niagara Falls, Lockport, North Tonawanda, and throughout Erie County and Niagara County. A+ BBB rating. 32 five-star Google reviews. No repairs required. No agent fees. Title Companies Buffalo NY › | Homeowner Resources ›
Questions About Your Title?
Call Us.
We have navigated Erie County title issues on 300+ WNY closings. If something showed up in your abstract, we’ve probably seen it — and resolved it.