Old tires cannot go in Buffalo curbside trash or dumpsters — they require separate disposal. Free and paid options below. ↓
TIRE DISPOSAL
BUFFALO NY
Where to get rid of old tires in Erie and Niagara County — free drop-off, licensed WNY companies, retail dealers, and pickup services. Most people have no idea these options exist.
DISCLAIMER: Nickel City Buyers, LLC is not affiliated with, compensated by, or endorsing any tire disposal company or program listed here. Hours, fees, and accepted items change — always call ahead before making a trip. Last updated March 2026.
300M
Tires discarded in the US every year
FREE
City of Buffalo tire drop-off — 4 Saturdays per year
$2.50
NYS recycling fee already paid on every new tire
75+
Years combined experience at Geiter Done WNY
Section 01 — City of Buffalo Free Program
Free City of Buffalo Tire Drop-Off
The City of Buffalo runs a free tire recycling program four Saturdays per year at the Broadway Garage. City residents only — free of charge. Call 311 to get the current year’s dates before you load up the car.
Official City Program — Free
197 Broadway
Buffalo, NY 14204
City of Buffalo Broadway Garage — Free Tire Drop-Off
This program is for City of Buffalo residents only. Suburb residents — Cheektowaga, Amherst, Hamburg, Tonawanda and all others — see the Geiter Done and retail dealer options below.
How It Works
On the designated Saturdays, bring your tires to the Broadway Garage drop-off. No appointment needed — just show up during the collection window. Tires are then transported to licensed recycling facilities.
Pro tip: Call 311 in January each year to get the full list of 2026 Saturday dates — they fill up fast. Mark them on your calendar. You don’t want to miss the one Saturday that works for you and wait another three months.
Part of Mayor Sean M. Ryan’s “34 and More” initiative — Buffalo’s campaign to exceed the national 34% recycling diversion rate. Visit buffalorecycles.org for the official City recycling calendar.
Why Old Tires Are a
Real Health Hazard
in WNY
That stack of tires in the garage or backyard isn’t just an eyesore. It’s a health hazard — especially in Buffalo’s warm and wet summers.
- Tires collect and hold standing water from rain and snow melt
- Mosquitoes breed in as little as one teaspoon of standing water
- A single tire can produce hundreds of mosquitoes per week
- WNY’s Aedes albopictus mosquito can carry West Nile Virus
- Tire stockpiles are also fire hazards — burning rubber releases toxic compounds
- Illegal dumping of tires is a NYS Environmental Conservation Law violation
The WNY Summer Problem:
Erie County’s combination of heavy spring rain, warm summers, and humid nights creates ideal mosquito breeding conditions. A single backyard with stacked tires can affect an entire neighborhood. Erie County Health Department actively monitors standing water complaints during mosquito season.
Section 02 — WNY Licensed Disposal + Pickup Services
Geiter Done, 1-800-GOT-JUNK & LoadUp
For residents outside the City of Buffalo, or anyone who needs more than 4 Saturdays per year, these are your best options — a WNY-based specialist, national pickup services, and same-day convenience.
WNY’s Tire Disposal Specialist — Since 2005
Geiter Done of WNY
geiterdone.com · (716) 895-8121 · 300 Greene St, Buffalo NY 14206
Buffalo’s dedicated tire disposal company — established 2005, 75+ years combined management experience, 35,000 sq ft Buffalo facility. Licensed in NYS and Pennsylvania. Has performed a 40,000-tire cleanup for Erie County and an 800,000-tire cleanup for the State of Pennsylvania. This is the serious option for large quantities or commercial tire disposal.
National · Buffalo Location · Same-Day
1-800-GOT-JUNK? Buffalo
1800gotjunk.com · (716) 986-9909
Same-day tire removal throughout Erie and Niagara Counties if you book early. Full-service — they come to you, load the tires, haul them away. Works with certified tire recycling facilities around Buffalo. Good option when tires are in an inconvenient location (backyard, basement, storage unit) or when you can’t transport them yourself.
Online Booking · Upfront Pricing
LoadUp Buffalo
goloadup.com/buffalo · Online booking
Modern online booking with upfront pricing — no waiting for a call back or on-site estimate. Serves all Erie County. Claims pricing 20–30% lower than similar services. Next-day or same-day pickup when booked before noon. Good choice if you want to know the price before committing.
Local WNY · Full Cleanout + Tires
Rapid Junk Removal
rapidjunkremoval.com · WNY local
Local family-owned WNY junk removal company that handles tires alongside other junk removal. Best option when you have tires plus other items to dispose of — furniture, appliances, debris — and want to handle everything in one call. Also offers dumpster rentals if you prefer to DIY.
Section 03 — Retail Tire Dealers
Tire Dealers That Accept Old Tires
Erie County’s guidance is straightforward — bring old tires to any retail tire dealer. Most accept a small number of passenger tires for a nominal fee. Convenient if you’re already getting new tires installed.
| Dealer | Buffalo Area Locations | Disposal Policy | Fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mavis Discount Tire | 2190 Delaware Ave, North Buffalo NY 14216 · (716) 869-1745 · Multiple WNY locations | Accepts up to 4 passenger tires per person per year · must be unmounted, not full of water, not muddy | $1.00 per tire |
| Discount Tire | Multiple WNY locations | Accepts old tires with or without new purchase · passenger and light truck tires | $1–$3 per tire typical |
| Firestone Complete Auto Care | Multiple WNY locations | Accepts old tires — call your local store to confirm current policy | $2–$4 per tire typical |
| Pep Boys | Multiple WNY locations | Accepts old tires for recycling — typically with or without service | $1–$3 per tire typical |
| Any Local Auto Dealer or Garage | Throughout WNY | Most garages accept old tires as part of routine service — ask when scheduling | Varies · Often included in service |
NYS Tire Recycling Fee: New York State’s Environmental Conservation Law already imposes a $2.50 waste tire management and recycling fee on every new tire sold in the state. This fee funds NYS tire recycling programs. When you buy new tires at any WNY dealer, that $2.50 per tire is already baked into the transaction — which is why dealers can accept your old tires at a low fee or free with purchase.
What Actually Happens
to Your Old Tires
Recycled tires don’t just disappear — they get a second life. The rubber is shredded into crumb rubber and repurposed across dozens of industries. Your old Cheektowaga garage tires may end up on a playground, a running track, or a highway shoulder.
The Recycling Process
01 Tires are shredded into large chunks at the facility
02 Steel wire is magnetically separated and recycled
03 Rubber is ground into crumb rubber particles
04 Crumb rubber becomes playground surfaces, tracks, turf infill, asphalt, and more
This Is What’s Waiting on the Other Side.
One call. One trip. Years of tire buildup — gone.
Common Questions
Tire Disposal Buffalo — FAQ
Can I throw old tires in a dumpster or curbside trash in Buffalo?
How do I dispose of tires in Buffalo if I don’t live in the City?
How many tires can I drop off and is it really free?
I inherited a property with dozens of old tires in the backyard — what do I do?
Why are old tires such a problem in WNY specifically?
What happens to tires after they’re recycled in Buffalo?
WNY Homeowner Note
Tire Removal Before a Property Sale
If you’re preparing to sell a Buffalo-area property with old tires on site — whether in a garage, backyard, or storage area — proper disposal is required before closing in most cases. Tires left on a property can complicate title transfer and create liability.
The good news: Geiter Done can handle large-volume cleanups quickly, and 1-800-GOT-JUNK offers same-day service. For inherited properties with tire piles, NCB buys the property as-is and handles all disposal after closing — no cost to you.
Note: Tire disposal costs may be deductible as a property maintenance expense in certain circumstances. Consult your CPA — this is general information only, not tax advice.
Nickel City Buyers
NCB Believes In Giving Back
Since 2013, NCB has quietly donated to Buffalo organizations — the Buffalo City Mission, Toys for Tots, the Castellani Art Museum Sock Drive at Niagara University, and Books for Kids/Project Flight. Not for press. Because this is our community.
“We buy houses in this city. We profit from transactions in this community. The least we can do — and we mean that literally — is give something back.”
SELLING A BUFFALO PROPERTY
WITH TIRES & JUNK?
If you sell to Nickel City Buyers — you don’t need to haul away a single tire before closing. Tires, furniture, appliances, everything — NCB buys properties completely as-is and handles all disposal after closing at no cost to you.
Part of the Buffalo NY Moving & Disposal Resource Guide — the most complete homeowner resource in Western New York.
Service Area — Nickel City Buyers, LLC
Nickel City Buyers, LLC · 3842 Harlem Rd STE 400-339, Cheektowaga, NY 14215 · (716) 557-7005 · nickelcitybuyers.com · Buying houses across Buffalo, Cheektowaga, Amherst, Tonawanda, Lackawanna, West Seneca, Hamburg, Orchard Park, Lancaster, Depew, Kenmore, Williamsville, East Aurora, Clarence, Grand Island, Niagara Falls, Lockport, North Tonawanda, Lewiston, Youngstown, Wheatfield, Pendleton, Newfane and all of Erie and Niagara County since 2013. A+ BBB · 5.0 Google. This tire disposal guide serves all Western New York residents including all Erie County and Niagara County municipalities.